Private Barrel Picks
What a Private Barrel Pick IsMost Kentucky distilleries let a retailer, bar or club taste samples from several barrels of one whiskey and buy the barrel it likes. That barrel… Read more
65 products
What a Private Barrel Pick IsMost Kentucky distilleries let a retailer, bar or club taste samples from several barrels of one whiskey and buy the barrel it likes. That barrel… Read more
65 products
Most Kentucky distilleries let a retailer, bar or club taste samples from several barrels of one whiskey and buy the barrel it likes. That barrel is bottled on its own with the buyer's name on a tag or label, and the run is as large as the cask yields. Each distillery names its program: Four Roses Private Selection, Knob Creek Single Barrel Select, Maker's Mark Private Selection, Russell's Reserve Private Barrel Selection, Elijah Craig Private Barrel, Sazerac Barrel Select. Main Street Liquor has chosen barrels through several of these; this page holds those picks alongside barrels other shops, bars and people selected.
| Distillery | Picks on the store | Chosen by, as titled |
|---|---|---|
| Buffalo Trace and Barton 1792 (Sazerac) | Blanton's Single Barrel 750mL, Blanton's 375mL, W.L. Weller Full Proof, Buffalo Trace Single Barrel, Rock Hill Farms, 1792 Full Proof, 1792 Single Barrel | Store picks |
| Jack Daniel, Lynchburg | Single Barrel Barrel Proof, 127.1 proof, Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye, 129.3 proof | Store picks |
| Woodford Reserve, Versailles | Double Oaked Single Barrel Strength, Distiller's Select 110 Proof | Store picks |
| James B. Beam, Clermont | Knob Creek Cask Strength Single Barrel Select, Maker's Mark Private Selection "Yam Jam" | Store pick; Kelsey Plum |
| Heaven Hill, Bardstown | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof "Bourbon For President", Elijah Craig Single Barrel | Private barrel; Max Homa |
| Four Roses, Lawrenceburg | Private Selection OBSF Barrel Strength | Private Selection |
| Wild Turkey, Lawrenceburg | Private Selection Single Barrel Rye | Private Selection |
| Others | George Dickel 9 Year, Penelope 10 Year, WhistlePig 10 Year | Named on each product |
A regular single barrel is chosen by the distillery; a store pick is chosen by the buyer from the samples offered. What the buyer controls is which barrel, and sometimes the proof: Knob Creek's Single Barrel Select ships at 120 proof while its Cask Strength option is bottled undiluted, Russell's Reserve picks are 110 proof and non-chill filtered, and Maker's Mark Private Selection is finished with ten staves from five stave types for about nine weeks, then bottled at cask strength.
Look for three marks. The selector's name, on a sticker, neck tag or printed label, says who tasted the samples. A barrel number, often with a warehouse or rick, identifies the cask. A hand-written or stickered proof means barrel strength, and the number belongs to that barrel alone. Where a product title names a bar, golfer, athlete or another shop, that party chose the barrel.
See also allocated bourbon, in bottled in bond bourbon and in the full bourbon collection.
A single barrel that a retailer tasted and bought whole through a distillery's barrel program. The distillery bottles that one barrel for the store, so the run is limited to what that cask yields and cannot be repeated.
The same thing as a store pick or private selection: one barrel chosen by a buyer, bottled on its own and labeled with the buyer's name and the barrel number. Distilleries use their own names for it, such as Four Roses Private Selection or Knob Creek Single Barrel Select.
A regular single barrel is picked by the distillery; a store pick is picked by the retailer from several samples. The whiskey comes from the same warehouses. Some programs also bottle picks at a higher proof than the shelf bottle, such as Knob Creek's cask strength option.
They are different rather than better. Every barrel varies, and a pick is one buyer's choice among the samples offered that day. The value is knowing who chose it and that the bottle cannot be repeated once the barrel is gone.
On this page: Buffalo Trace and Barton 1792 through Sazerac Barrel Select, Jack Daniel's, Woodford Reserve, Knob Creek and Maker's Mark from Beam Suntory, Elijah Craig from Heaven Hill, Four Roses, Wild Turkey, Bardstown Bourbon Company, Angel's Envy, George Dickel, Penelope, Green River, Old Elk, WhistlePig and Caribou Crossing.
Those whose product title says so: Blanton's in 750mL and 375mL, W.L. Weller Full Proof, Buffalo Trace Single Barrel, Rock Hill Farms, two 1792 barrels, two Jack Daniel's barrel proof barrels, two Woodford Reserve barrels and a Knob Creek Cask Strength barrel. Picks titled with another shop, bar or person were chosen by that party.